Nutrition

A Thanksgiving Menu Tune-Up

Holidays bring joy — and often food anxiety. How to cook, how to serve, and, finally, how much? In an era when we all seem to be on a diet, do you give in and make everything Grandma did?

Today’s goal is not to re-create a Norman Rockwell painting, but to make a festive meal you will be happy to serve on Thanksgiving Day. The biggest change: If you don’t need to present the whole turkey for carving at the table, cook a turkey breast instead. Either way, use a food thermometer. This ensures a safe minimum internal temperature of 165°F (73.8°C) has been reached to destroy bacteria and prevent foodborne illnesses.


Cooking times

If you start with a fresh turkey breast, you don’t have to worry about thawing it in time to cook for dinner. It will likely come with directions and a pop-up timer, but here are the basics: A 5-pound to 6-pound turkey breast roasted at 325°F (162.7°C) will cook in about 2 hours. Basting with butter or oil isn’t needed. You’ll remove the skin before slicing and serving, because that's where most of the fat is. 

The breast will supply about 3 pounds of solid white meat. A 3-ounce serving — about the size of a deck of cards — contains 115 calories, 26 grams protein, less than a gram of fat, 71 mg cholesterol, no carbohydrate or fiber, and 44 mg sodium.

Here’s the skinny on other holiday favorites:

  • Gravy. A turkey breast won’t provide a lot of juice. So add some nonfat chicken broth. To thicken, start with a tablespoon of flour or cornstarch dissolved in a half cup of cold water. Stir it with a whisk. Add chopped mushrooms for a giblet texture.

  • Vegetables. Instead of adding things to your vegetables, let them be themselves. Steam the beans and use fresh-cut veggies as an appetizer tray, maybe with a little low-fat dip. Plain sweet potatoes—hold the marshmallows, please—add color to your plate.

  • Dessert. Skip the big pies and do a tray of mini-tarts or bite-sized cakes (petit fours) from a bakery or the freezer. 


Talking turkey

  • The great plate debate. Consider using 8-inch plates and leaving Grandma’s 10-inch china in the cupboard. Smaller plates will help people choose smaller portions without having to think about it.

  • Fuss less. Cleanup is easier with throwaway foil roasting pans. Aluminum foil makes a perfect cover to keep your turkey breast from over-browning and your outside-the-bird stuffing from drying out.

  • Plan your menu. Shoot for quality, not quantity. You don’t need more food than your family and guests will eat, or more leftovers than you can enjoy. As you plan the menu, ask what they’d miss if it weren’t there.

  • Call for help. You can call the USDA Meat and Poultry Hotline toll-free at 1-888-MPHotline (1-888-674-6854) from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. weekdays except federal holidays. On Thanksgiving Day, it’s open from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. Check out the USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service website at www.fsis.usda.gov . Email questions may be sent to MPHotline@usda.gov

Author: Greatorex, Susan

Online Medical Reviewer: Heather M Trevino BSN RNC

Online Medical Reviewer: Marianne Fraser MSN RN

Online Medical Reviewer: Rita Sather RN

Date Last Reviewed: 01/01/2024

© 2000-2025 The StayWell Company, LLC. All rights reserved. This information is not intended as a substitute for professional medical care. Always follow your healthcare professional's instructions.
doctor icon

Find the right provider to meet your needs

From primary care to specialty services and more.

Find a Doctor
appointment clock icon

Call for an Appointment

Offering personalized care at more than 20 clinics across three cities and two states.

Call Now
Related Articles
Read article
Wellness
MyPlate Worksheet: 1,400 Calories

Your calorie needs are about 1,400 calories a day. These are the USDA guidelines for your daily recommended amount of each food group.

Read article
Wellness
Healthy Eating on the Go

Wherever your family goes, healthy eating can still be easy for you and fun for your kids. Here are tips to make smart choices while you're out.

Read article
Wellness
Decoding Popular Diets

These diets may be trending, but are they right for you? Only you and your healthcare provider can answer that question. Use the information below as a starting point for your conversations.

Read article
Wellness
Vitamin E Supplements

Vitamin E has more than one form. The natural ones are found in fats and oils. Synthetic versions also exist. The vitamin E compound that is most useful in the body is called alpha-tocopherol. This is also the most common form of vitamin E. It can occur naturally or be synthetic.